What fell out of the archive
6 October 2025On working with the archive

Three numbers get mixed up whenever Benevolence is described. Around 1,200 films were collected over four years. About 600 of them were actually watched through, scene by scene, and every scene in which a man and a woman interact was cut out and filed. The finished film uses 94. Those are three different things: an archive, a corpus and an edit.
The obvious objection is that a film about a convention will find the convention, because that is what was being looked for. It is a fair objection and the answer is in how the edit was made. A scene did not enter the pool because of what happened in it. It entered if it could be matched to another scene on movement, framing and composition; if the camera moved, since a static shot has nothing to match against; and if it fitted the arc the whole film follows, from guiding to violence to what the films call love. Those are formal conditions. The gesture was what made a scene usable, not what made it chosen.
The conditions also explain what fell out. The 1930s are in the archive and almost absent from the film, because their shots are static. Widescreen is absent because I would not crop, so the corpus stops around 1953. What survived those two filters is 1945 to 1949.